Trusted by 729 journals in 43 countries729 journals · 43 countries
Make an Editorial Decision in OMP 3.5 – OMP 3.5 video tutorial

OMP 3.5 video tutorialsVideo 8 of 15

3:55

Video 8 of 15Editors3:55 minEnglish subtitles

Learn how an editor makes a decision after peer review in Open Monograph Press (OMP) 3.5: read and rate the review, thank the reviewer, request revisions (with or without a new review round), check the revised file, and accept the book for copyediting.

In this video

  1. 0:31Part A · Read the reviews
  2. 1:11Part B · Request revisions
  3. 2:11Part C · Accept the book
  4. 3:01Common mistakes
  5. 3:18Checklist

Step by step

The full text of the video, section by section. Click a time to play the video from that point.

Introduction0:00

Welcome. In this video you will learn how an editor makes a decision after the review in Open Monograph Press 3.5. You will read and rate the review, request revisions from the author, check the revised file, and accept the book for copyediting.

Before you start0:18

Before you start, you need an editor account assigned to the submission, and at least one submitted review. Take time to read the reviews and the manuscript before you decide.

Part A · Read the reviews0:31

When a reviewer submits a review, the book appears on the Editor Dashboard under Reviews submitted. Click it. Click View to open the submission.

In the Reviewers list, click Read Review next to the reviewer's name. Read the comments for the author and editor, the comments for the editor only, and open any reviewer files. You can rate the quality of the review.

The reviewer does not see this rating. Then click Confirm. The status is now Complete.

You can click Thank Reviewer to send a thank-you e-mail.

Part B · Request revisions1:11

Now decide. Request Revisions asks the author for changes. Accept Submission sends the book to copyediting.

Create New Review Round starts another review. Decline Submission rejects the book. Click Request Revisions.

Choose whether the revised version needs a new round of peer review. For minor changes, keep the first option and click Next. This decision has two steps: Notify Authors, and Notify Reviewers.

The e-mail to the author already includes the reviewers' comments at the bottom. Check that no reviewer names appear, then click Continue. The reviewer is informed and thanked.

Click Record Decision. The decision is recorded. The author can now upload a revised version.

Part C · Accept the book2:11

When the author uploads the revision, the book appears under Author revisions submitted. Open it. The revised file is under Revisions Uploaded.

Download it and check the changes, and read the author's message in Review Discussions. If the changes are good, click Accept Submission. Notify the authors, notify the reviewers, and select the files.

Click Continue after each e-mail. Select the revised manuscript for the copyediting stage, then click Record Decision. The submission is accepted.

Click View Submission Summary. The book is now in the Copyediting stage. This is shown in the next video.

Common mistakes3:01

Some common mistakes. A decision is made before all reviews are read. Reviewer names are left in the e-mail to the author.

The old file is selected instead of the revised one. And a new review round is chosen for very small changes.

Checklist3:18

To sum up. Open Reviews submitted, read the review, rate it, and confirm. To ask for changes, click Request Revisions, choose whether a new round is needed, notify, and record the decision.

When the revision arrives, check the revised file. Then click Accept Submission, select the revised file, and record the decision. In the next video, you will learn about copyediting.

All names, books, institutions and addresses in this video are fictional examples.

Tags:

Comments are closed

0
0
Your Cart
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop